Machine God Metaphors Eat Your Brain
Henry Farrell argues that the "machine gods" metaphor dominating AI debate — treating AI as either a benevolent or malevolent deity — throws away exactly the information needed to navigate the moment. He places Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nick Land as the two most influential policy intellectuals in the US conversation, and argues this is not a good thing. The essay proposes an alternative framing of AI as a social and cultural technology rather than a godlike entity.
Why I recommend it: The author acknowledges his own dog in the fight — he and co-authors developed the competing "AI as social and cultural technology" approach the essay advocates for. Programmable Mutter is a Substack newsletter; some posts may be for paying subscribers, but this one is free.